Our March Towards Madness

img_0115

Remember Devo?

Cultural differences have existed as long as humanity. Our social forms and norms defined by place, time and strength of voice— dictating ethics for everyone belonging to a particular society or group.  In the past, we would look at other cultures, see their ways, and make arguments for or against, but generally, as we rarely commingled, we left well enough alone.

In the 80’s or 90’s, as we became more global, the idea of cultural relativism gained ground.  Our lives intersected more and more with people different from our own, and with this came a certain level of understanding and acceptance…not perfect by any means, but there was a desire by many groups to get along.  In those days, we marched to ensure society as a whole would respect each other’s differences and ensure equal treatment under the law and in our workplaces.  Diversity became popular.

Over time, many went further to say all cultures with their various beliefs and norms, were equal– equally good, on par with any other in terms of their rights to practice whatever. Every way became relative. This is when things began to get a bit contentious as it became hard to agree on the righteousness of it all.

I think we have reached some sort of tipping point where little is making sense and we’ve lost our civility.  As humanity we are actually devoluting into marching masses fighting for kitchen sink of “causes”– anything we are or are not in terms of gender, sexuality, religion (except for Christians and certainly not the dreaded “evangelicals” who have beliefs that are too far right and unaccepting apparently…) and “status” such as legal, migrant, illegal etc.

Having studied philosophy, I’ve argued for and against positions just for the fun of it– without personal investment.  Each position was taken based on foundational principles that were grounded– proven by ancient thinker who laid them first.  You could choose a foundation and begin to build and reflect upon a structure of thought.  The outcomes differed based on the chose base argument and comparisons could be made as to the merits. This is what is slipping away…a respect for well-grounded thought and the ability to logically discern any truth.

No. Let me correct myself on that.  Society is not losing the ability to discern any truth, we are condemning the idea that there is “a truth.”

In fact, it has become popular to consider anyone who declares a cornerstone for living their life, as narrow-minded when in fact they have thought through their mere human existence, admitted they are limited in knowledge, and have sought a higher authority.

Ask yourself, is a self-reliant know-it-all who defines their reality really intelligent?  On the other hand, what about the person who is afraid to commit to any real truth, who jumps on whatever bandwagon because it is the popular thing to do and in the next turn contradicts their former position because it is a new day?  Or could it be, that the individual who chooses a particular certainty, even an unprovable one, and commits to their chosen overarching truth as the truth by which they can live and die, the one thinking this life well through?

When you march for everything you are in a sense marching for nothing at all, because without a foundation, the first cause as it were, the sand under your feet will eventually shift leaving you groundless.

#Marchtomadness #nothingwithoutGod

img_0114

Advertisements

3 thoughts on “Our March Towards Madness

  1. completely agree, you expressed my same thoughts on recent events in a more clear, philosophical way. I have studied philosophy also, alongside it I studied Sociology, and there, particularly at university, I noticed this same dangerous trend to a relativism that has gone too far

    Liked by 1 person

  2. I read your post the other day, and have waited a few days before replying. As someone studying cultures and how what learn from them at the moment, my original reply to your post had stretched into the middle distance! (I’ve spared you that…) Yet it would have seemed trite to simply reply “good post”. I shall content myself by highlighting one point that you make which rings very true.

    Your comment relating to norms being defined by time, place and strength of voice is excellent, and in a way sums up what culture is. Our social norms are in a near-constant state of evolution, and what is regarded as “normal” today may well be viewed with horror tomorrow. And indeed, cross-cultural norms have much in common with this notion too, an area with which I know you have considerable experience.

    My thanks for your thoughts here, it had me scribbling notes into the margin of part of my thesis with points to expand upon, as well as providing – as always – food for thought.

    All the best!

    Liked by 1 person

    • I’m glad it provided some food for fodder HM. Our ever changing values is something that bothers me greatly. Certain groups are very pushy about it as well. I read recently that young adults who were surveyed (I don’t have any details at this point) overwhelmingly thought that not recycling was a worse scourge on our society than porn. Maybe so, but I’d like to hear that argument laid out with some foundation and data at least. These days we are so loose with our talk and judgments.

      I’m very interested in your thesis. I’d like to read it someday if you are willing to share.

      Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s